navy ship accidents by year

As Belknap scraped along Kennedys port side, ruptured JP-5 lines on Kennedy poured fuel onto Belknap, resulting in a fire on both ships. Only one was rescued and the other three drowned. Figure 1: Naval Accidents by Year, 1945-1988 . The US Navy, and the Seventh Fleet in particular, now faces challenges in living up to the image of being the best navy in the world. The joint U.S.Australian board of inquiry proved to be quite contentious and would mark a low point in U.S. NavyRoyal Australian Navy relations due to U.S. efforts to place at least part of the blame on Melbourne while U.S. Navy officers conceded privately that Evans was wholly at fault. In the 19 months since the fatal collision, the Navy's Readiness Reform Oversight Council has made "significant progress" in implementing reforms called for in several top-level Navy reviews . A US Navy plane crashed into the ocean southeast of Okinawa on Wednesday afternoon, marking at least the sixth apparent accident involving a Navy asset in East Asian waters this year. The frigate was towed to Souda Bay, then to dry dock in Toulon, France, for repairs. Had the (commanding officer) and (executive officer) critiqued the near-collision, they may have identified the root causes uncovered by this investigation., When contacted by Navy Times, Shu recalled the incident that took place just east of the Tsushima Strait, a normally busy and recognized waterway., As I was heading down the ladderwell to my cabin, I heard five short blasts and felt the ship back, Shu said. The region has ranked first in shipping losses over the past decade. Benson, his executive officer who would soon fleet up to replace him as skipper, plus Bensons future second-in-command, Cmdr. The Navy said the deadly collision was "preventable. Thankfully, the Navy and its sailors are both alive and well, but the tragedy reminds us of the importance of prevention and safety. Encountering steering control problems near the Strait of Malacca, McCain crossed ahead and was struck by Liberian-flagged tanker Alnic MC before dawn. It also lists the sinking of the Spanish fishing boat Barcona, which accidentally snagged the attack submarine USS Houston and was dragged underwater. During the first day of exercise Cobra Gold in Thailand a landing craft, air cushion (LCAC) hovercraft off Essex struck and killed a U.S. sailor from Beach Master Unit One, Detachment Western Pacific, Sasebo, Japan. Search and rescue effort underway, Navy says. Feb. 9, 2001: The Greeneville, a Los Angeles-class fast attack submarine, collided with a Japanese fishing boat, the Ehime Maru, off the coast of Oahu, Hawaii. While conducting exercises in the Tyrrhenian Sea, destroyer Newman K. Perry accidentally rammed carrier Shangri-La, holing the carrier below the waterline, which was quickly patched. The aft half of the destroyer remained afloat, scraping along the starboard side of Melbourne until the Australians could secure the section alongside, allowing the destroyers crew to cross over. However, 2020 was the first year in the last five that shipping losses have not fallen from year ago, possibly signaling that losses are stabilizing around this level. USS Solar (DE-221) following the explosion of forward magazine while at Naval Ammunition Depot, Earle, New Jersey, on 30 April 1946 (NHHC NH-104777). %PDF-1.3 % But Forts investigation pointed to a disturbing pattern of watchstanders failing to follow standing orders from a skipper and XO who often were inexplicably absent from the bridge, even when the warship was transiting potentially dangerous waters at night. While conducting firing practice northeast of Puerto Rico, an explosion in the No. The moral of this story is that despite recent accidents, the Navys current safety record is vastly better than it used to be. :The Power Clash Between the USand China in the Pacific, Deterrence under the dragons shadow: Vietnams military modernisation, Missed opportunities in the internationalised university, China may only seek a limited naval role in the Indian Ocean, India needs a more robust naval presence in Asia. He ultimately was not court-martialed, but his career in the Navy ended as a result of the collision. A scathing internal Navy probe into the 2017 collision that drowned seven sailors on the guided-missile destroyer Fitzgerald details a far longer list of problems plaguing the vessel, its crew and superior commands than the service has publicly admitted. The battle allowed the US Navy to flex its muscles, allowing it to completely destroy Irans military. Voge received hull damage but there were no injuries. In response to the reports findings, which blamed the ships crew, the Navy relieved two senior officers. The damage was bad enough that the ship was decommissioned and sold for scrap. To Fort, they also appeared to be led by officers who appeared indifferent to potentially life-saving lessons that shouldve been learned from other near-misses at sea, including a similar incident near Sasebo, Japan, that occurred only five weeks before the ACX Crystal collision, Fort wrote. As a result of confusion on the bridge of Frank E. Evans, the destroyer turned to starboard across Melbournes bow. Then, the. One junior officer spoke of a similar near-collision during low visibility, when a watch team finishing their shift failed to identify a vessel that was closing on them and wasnt being tracked, according to the report. Obtained by Navy Times, the dual-purpose investigation was overseen by Rear Adm. Brian Fort and submitted 41 days after the June 17, 2017, tragedy. The . Navy. While the final total of losses from the blockage have not yet been tallied, data from Lloyds list pegged the daily toll from the blockage at $9.6 billion a day. Theseincluded a lack of understanding and adherence to theConvention on the International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea (COLREGs), not least the need to proceed at a safe speed. Here's a few more collision events you may or may not have heard of. Geoff is a senior staff reporter for Military Times, focusing on the Navy. A combination of navigational errors, poor visibility, and swells caused by the Great Kanto Earthquake in Japan contributed to the disaster. Note ship is listing to starboard and steel bars installed to temporarily support her sail. Sean Babbitt. Parks went on to serve in the Vietnam War. 1986 Lost Ships if the Royal Navy 1794-1900, Mansell Publishing Ltd, UK Mechanical problems and human error were also considered factors in the crash. A liberty boat capsized in the Mediterranean off Les Salines de Hyeres, drowning eight sailors. We can use the story of the Indianapolis as a reminder of the importance of maritime safety. Aug. 19, 2016: The Louisiana, a nuclear ballistic-missile submarine, and the Eagleview, a Military Sealift Command support vessel, collided while conducting routine operations in the Strait of Juan de Fuca off the coast of Washington State. During George Washingtons presidency, the United States built the USS Constitution, which defeated five British warships. Robert Shu, to the bridge, according to Fort. Please sign in to access member exclusive content. As the carrier operated at night, it made a difficult turn to avoid the small ship. As Ara Piedra Bueno, she was in company with light cruiser Ara General Belgrano (ex-Phoenix) when Belgrano was torpedoed and sunk by British submarine HMS Conqueror in the Falklands War. Other risk challenges noted by Allianz include increased use of large vessels such as the Ever Given, which require specialized port facilities and salvage equipment; delays due to disruptive weather, which also causes container losses; political risk such as trade disputes; security issues such as piracy; cyber risks; and environmental concerns surrounding the emissions limits beginning in 2020, for example, and the increase of shipping in Arctic waters. During heavy weather in the Persian Gulf, the Samra foundered, taking two sailors of destroyer Petersons boarding team down with it. Navy) 25 Jan 2022. . About three weeks after the ACX Crystal disaster, Forts investigators sprang a rules of the road pop quiz on Fitzs officers. hbbd``b`$@D`?K!3D 0 a endstream endobj startxref 0 %%EOF 376 0 obj <>stream The 28-year-old Ingram was an information systems technician 2nd class aboard the ship. It and a small dhow, or sailing boat, collided in the Persian Gulf in 2004. On 2 June 1969, SH-3 helicopters from USS Kearsarge (CVS-33) join search-and-rescue operations over the stern section of USS Frank E. Evans (DD-754), as USS Everett F. Larson (DD-830) stands ready to offer assistance (right). The loss of these assets poses a significant national security risk and must be addressed as soon as possible. Upon reaching Long Beach Naval Shipyard, her bow was replaced by that of Seaman, an incomplete destroyer in the reserve fleet. .css-v1xtj3{display:block;font-family:FreightSansW01,Helvetica,Arial,Sans-serif;font-weight:100;margin-bottom:0;margin-top:0;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}@media (any-hover: hover){.css-v1xtj3:hover{color:link-hover;}}@media(max-width: 48rem){.css-v1xtj3{font-size:1.1387rem;line-height:1.2;margin-bottom:1rem;margin-top:0.625rem;}}@media(min-width: 40.625rem){.css-v1xtj3{line-height:1.2;}}@media(min-width: 48rem){.css-v1xtj3{font-size:1.18581rem;line-height:1.2;margin-bottom:0.5rem;margin-top:0rem;}}@media(min-width: 64rem){.css-v1xtj3{font-size:1.23488rem;line-height:1.2;margin-top:0.9375rem;}}Is Russias Only Aircraft Carrier Cursed? U.S. Navy ships operate in close proximity to other ships all the time, from steaming in formation with supply ships to sailing in busy sea lanes. However, he also describes theCowpensas a troubled ship, with a struggling crew that lacked training and experience. A fuel line rupture and fire on destroyer Manley resulted in one officer dying from burns and eight sailors suffering minor burns. While conducting underway training and a burial at sea off the Virginia Capes, a boiler explosion in the after fireroom of destroyer Basilone killed seven sailors and injured four more. Ten sailors from the McCain are missing but the vessel is now at Changi Naval Base in Singapore. June 17, 2017: Seven sailors were killed when the Fitzgerald, a destroyer, was broadsided by a Philippines-registered cargo ship, about 60 miles off the coast of Japan. The table listings are in decreasing order of the magnitude of casualties. The Fitzgerald collision was the worst incident in the US Navy since the attack on the Cole in 2000. An engine room fire on guided-missile destroyerDahlgrenkilled two crew members and injured four others. Bodies of some of the 10 missing sailors were found during a search for them. Seven destroyers, USS Deply, USS S.P. He covered Iraq and Afghanistan extensively and was most recently a reporter at the Chicago Tribune. All ships are vulnerable to problems from weather conditions, faulty design or human error. All communications and propulsion was lost. While passing the collier SSThomas Tracyoff Cape Henry, Virginia, seaplane tenderValcoursuffered a power failure and steering casualty, veering into the path of the collier, which rammedValcours starboard side. Your Privacy Choices: Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads. The subsequentinvestigationby Singaporean authorities found that people on the bridge ofMcCaindid not understand the ships steering system, and that many of the decisions leading to the accident were the result of poor judgement by the commanding officer. There are no definite figures on how many people were aboard the dhow, but the majority of them were fishing and traveling. The training film, I Relieve You, Sir (probably seen by all of us) was based on this collision. (An event I was very aware of while in the engineering spaces of Basilone on my 1977 midshipman 3/C cruise in the Mediterranean). Several common factors showed up in the investigations into theMcCainandFitzgeraldcollisions. During the Iran-Iraq War, Kuwait sent her to escort Kuwaiti oil tankers through the Persian Gulf. Vice Adm. Joseph Aucoin, the head of the U.S. Pacific Fleet, has been relieved of duty because of a "loss of confidence in his ability to command" after the collisions involving the USS John S. McCain and the USS Fitzgerald and the resulting deaths, the Navy said. There were no casualties, but the ship could not be recovered and was dismantled in place. Lowy Institute. Why Is a Russian Spy Ship Lurking Near Hawaii? K-134 vs USS Kitty Hawk: On March 21st, 1984 the Soviet attack submarine K-134 collided with the aircraft carrier USS Kitty Hawk in the Sea of Japan. The USS John S. McCain is seen after a collision in Singapore, Aug. 21, 2017. With the assistance of the fire department, they were able to isolate the ships reactor and firefighting systems. {-?c/]f1~L)bM?`7[8RTuf+iewl $ba $R20020pr1c/ ddfe +c Navy removes commander of 7th Fleet after string of accidents. Kenneth D. Bailey was repaired and made multiple Mediterranean deployments until she was sold to Iran for spare parts in 1975. But once the officer in charge had cleared the other ships stern, he became immediately aware that another vessel was on the opposite side of the ship they had just dodged, Fort wrote. The Interpreter features in-depth analysis & expert commentary on the latest international events, published daily by the Lowy Institute, Copyright 2023 Although Frank E. Evans had been operating in the Vietnam War zone prior to the collision and was scheduled to return to Vietnam upon conclusion of the multinational exercise, the collision took place just outside the designated zone, and the exercise was not deemed directly related to Vietnam operations. 2 16-inch gun turret of battleship Iowa killed 47 and injured 11. Maritime collisions involving two ships are considered rare, but this was the second collision involving an American naval destroyer since June. striking ships, accidents involving civilian interference, and cases of sabotage or arson. The Navy relieved Stephen G. Squires, the commanding officer of the Kennedy, after the episode. Seaman Recruit Ryan Sawyer Mays is not under confinement and is currently assigned to a squadron at Third Fleet. On December 7, 1941, a U.S. battleship named Arizona, the U.S. battleship that sank during the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, Oahu island, Hawaii, was sunk during the attack. USS George Washington and Nissho Maru: On April 9th, 1981 world's first nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarine, George Washington, collided with the cargo ship Nissho Maru off the coast of Sasebo, Japan. Most of the seven crew members killed on Belknap were trapped in engineering spaces below. Ten crew members on McCain died in a flooded berthing compartment. Damage to Columbus was minimal. The U.S. government paid the Philippine government $1.9 million for damage to the protected reef. The Guardian, the last US Navy ship to sink, had been lost at sea. Despite its significance, it was the last American ship to sink during World War II. Their report documents the routine, almost casual, violations of standing orders on a Fitz bridge that often lacked skippers and executive officers, even during potentially dangerous voyages at night through busy waterways. Problems were also evident with a large number of personnel on a warshipsbridge, with the OODrelying instead on non-commissioned quartermasters to fix the ships position and advise course adjustments. Crashback is an American naval term for ordering a ships engines to go full astern to avoid a collision or other accident. Published daily by the No one was injured. USS Hartford pulling into her home port at Groton, Connecticut. Ammen suffered extensive damage to the after deck house and below the waterline, but the crew controlled the flooding. Naval Academy, The Sullivan Brothers and the Assignment of Family Members, Historic Former U.S. Navy Bases and Stations, The African American Experience in the U.S. Navy, Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders in the U.S. Navy, Contributions of Native Americans to the U.S. Navy, The World Cruise of the Great White Fleet, Navy Underwater Archaeology Return Program, Annual Navy History and Heritage Awards - Main, Research Permits for Sunken & Terrestrial Military Craft, Scanning, Copyright & Citation Information, Obtain Duplications of Records and Photos, H-071-2: U.S. Navy Surface Ship Accidents Since World War II, H-003-2 Japanese Offensive and Navy Response, H-010-2 The Battle of the Eastern Solomons, H-010-5 Plaque from Samuel B. Roberts (FFG-58), H-011-1 Guadalcanal: Victory at Cape Esperance, H-011-3 Santa Cruz (Japanese Pyrrhic Victory), H-014-1 The Seizure of USS Pueblo (AGER-2), H-017-2: Operation Rolling Thunder Overview, H-019-4 "Black May": Battle of the Atlantic 1943, H-019-5 "Black Sunday": U-Boats off U.S. East Coast 1918, H-020-4: Submarine AL-2 Versus U-Boat UB-65, H-024-1 Bougainville and Victory in the Solomons, H-025-1 Operation GalvanicTarawa and Makin, H-028-1 Vietnam 1969 Navy Medal of Honor Awards, H-032-1 Operation Forager and the Battle of Philippine Sea, H-Gram Special Edition: Passing of Supreme Court Justice Stevens, H-045-3: 50th Anniversary of Apollo 13 Mission, H-046-1: Kamikaze Attack on USS Aaron Ward, H-048-1: Kamikaze Attacks on U.S. Flagships, H-048-2: Naval Battle of Okinawa (Continued), H-049-2: LCDR George Street's Medal of Honor, H-052-1: The U.S. Navy and the Atomic Bomb, H-053-1: The End of the Imperial Japanese Navy, H-053-3: Operation Desert Shield, September 1990, H-054-1: Inchon Landing and Naval Action in the Korean War, September-October 1950, H-054-2: Operation Desert Shield, October 1990, H-055-2: Operation Desert Shield, November 1990, H-055-: Attack on USS Cole (DDG-67) October 2000, H-056-2: Operation Desert Shield, December 1990-January 1991, H-057-1: Operations Downfall and Ketsugo November 1945, H-057-2: Operation Cherry Blossoms at Night, H-058-1: Operation Desert Storm in January 1991, H-058-2: Korean War - Communist China Offensive, H-059-1: Operation Desert Storm in Feb-Mar 1991, H-059-2: 50th Anniversary of the Vietnam War, H-061-1 Korea: U.S. Navy Operations, March-July 1951, H-061-3 Desert Storm: Sealift, Seabees, Navy Medicine, H-063-3: The Battle of Shimonoseki Strait, H-064-1: Close Quarters Antisubmarine Warfare (Part 1), H-064-2: Close Quarters Antisubmarine Warfare (Part 2), H-064-3: Close Quarters Antisubmarine Warfare (Part 3), H-069-1: "The Covered Wagon: USS Langley (CV-1), H-070-1: The Vietnam War Easter Offensive, Part 1, H-071-3: The Sacrifices of USS Neosho and USS Sims, H-074-1: The Vietnam War Easter Offensive, Part 2, H-075-1: U.S. Navy vs. Soviets Overwater Dogfight, H-075-2: Short History of U.S. Navy Accidents and Non-Combat Losses, Casualties: U.S. Navy and Marine Corps Personnel Killed and Injured in Selected Accidents and Other Incidents Not Directly the Result of Enemy Action. This is the second time in six months that a US naval destroyer has collided with another vessel. Cowpenswas forced to crashback when one of the vessels escorting the carrier cutclosely across the bow. At about 0300, destroyer Frank E. Evans was operating in a multinational formation of British, Australian, and New Zealand ships, centered on Australian aircraft carrier HMAS Melbourne in the South China Sea. The Barcona sank, and one crewman on the tugboat drowned. The collision caused significant structural damage to the stern of Voge. Turn on desktop notifications for breaking stories about interest? When the flared bow of Crystal ripped open the superstructure of the destroyer at the commanders cabin, CO Cmdr. The OOD admitted she had violated the commanding officers standing orders several times during the overnight transit off the coast of Japan. A flash fire in the engineering spaces of minesweeper Exultant off Savannah, Georgia, killed five crew members. There was damage to the hulls of both the Eagleview and the Louisiana. As a result, the lost crew members were deemed ineligible for inclusion on the Vietnam Memorial Wall. During a storm off Virginia, destroyer Daly took a 65 degree roll from a rogue wave. A fast attack submarine named the Greeneville collided with a fishing vessel off the coast of Japan. Collisions involving U.S. ships are more common than you might think. This is the specially designed and constructed high-strength compartment within which the all-welded primary system and nuclear FTZs command leadership was unaware of just how far below standards their command had drifted, wrote Fort, a surface warfare officer with more than a quarter-century of experience. The accident claimed at least 85 lives. The table listings are in decreasing order of the magnitude of casualties. Here are a handful of other recent collisions involving United States Navy vessels at sea several of which included fatalities. Although Shu couldnt recall how close the two vessels got to each other, he insisted that the incident wasnt a near-collision and that his bridge team reacted appropriately and later assured him that they had a good picture of the vessels around their destroyer. About 60 to 100 crew members were rescued from the water, including some by Melbournes crew. Global Shipping Losses By Number Of Vessels, 2011-2020 (1), Global Shipping Losses By Number Of Vessels By Region, 2011-2020 (1), S. China, Indochina, Indonesia and Philippines, British Isles, N. Sea, Eng. Bryce Benson, and Lt. Natalie Combs, who ran the CIC, are battling similar charges in court but contend unlawful command influence by senior leaders scuttled any chance for fair trials. The Kennedy, which was engaged in night air operations at the time, had made a hard turn to avoid the tiny vessel. The US Navy has lost a steady stream of ships since World War II. Coppock failed to do weeks later when the ACX Crystal loomed out of the darkness, the report states. While operating 100 miles east of Hong Kong, a fire in the engine room of combat stores shipWhite Plainskilled six crew members. Prosecutors argued that complacency was the standard onFitzgerald. When Fort arrived at her CIC desk, he found a stack of paperwork Combs abandoned: She was most likely consumed and distracted by a review of Operations Department paperwork for the three and a half hours of her watch prior to the collision, Fort wrote. In 2018, 3.0% of the reported marine casualties were very serious (95), 25.9% serious, 53.5% less serious and 17.6% were marine incidents. To avoid future losses, the navy must invest in new technologies and improve safety measures. Mark Turney/U.S. The crew had been pulled from event to event to include the memorial service and the dignified send off and the last thing anyone had been thinking about was how many lights a 50 meter towing vessel on inland waterways should have.. Seventy three of the 275 crewmembers on the Evans were killed. (Navy). Destroyer Collet collided with destroyer Ammen in dense fog off Newport Beach, California. Some radar controls didnt work and he soon discovered crew members who didnt know how to use them anyway. Hearst Magazine Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Dozens were injured. The two junior officers on the bridge of Evans at the time pleaded guilty to charges of dereliction of duty and negligence. The Fitzs commanding officer, Cmdr. Both ships resupply Navy warships for the United States Fifth Fleet, which is based in Manama, Bahrain. Two other destroyer crew members were injured. Retired Colonel Steve Ganyard analyzes the latest ship collision that comes on the heels of the USS Fitzgerald disaster and discusses the military and foreign policy impact of accidents like this. A Navy guided-missile destroyer collided with a commercial vessel. The dhow sank immediately, killing all aboard. The ships story is tragic in many ways. One sailor was killed aboard ship and five others were lost overboard. Guided-missile destroyer Claude V. Ricketts (DDG-5) and destroyer Bordelon (DD-881) came alongside Belknap to assist in fighting the fire and were showered by debris when Belknaps 3-inch ready ammunition locker cooked off. Is Russias Only Aircraft Carrier Cursed? Two crew members on McMorris were killed and seven injured. Seven sailors were killed when the merchant ships bulbous bow pierced Fitzgeralds hull below the waterline and flooded an enlisted berthing area. No injuries were reported. Inadvertent contact between ships, no matter how thorough the precautions, is inevitable. A liberty launch capsized off Newport, Rhode Island, drowning 19 personnel. Although there were no fatalities or injuries, the ship was damaged beyond repair. It must also be noted that the U.S. Navy and the Soviet Navy, and to a lesser degree British, French, and Chinese navies, routinely operate warships and submarines with nuclear . There were no injuries. Lee, USS Young, USS Woodbury, USS Nicholas, USS Fuller, and USS Chauncey were so heavily damaged they were later scrapped, and two other destroyers sustained minor damage. 2 Oct. 2001. . "When tragedy like this is one too many, and while each of these four are unique, they cannot be viewed in isolation," Admiral Scott Swift said during a press conference today. Disasters with great loss of life can occur in times of armed conflict. Benevolence sank within 20 minutes, about 4 miles off the Golden Gate Bridge, with 23 dead (505 aboard were rescued). Crews were able to eventually extinguish the blaze, though it did burn for around 20 hours. The Suez Canal Authority impounded the ship after it was freed and sought about $600 million in damages, caused by blocking the canal. 10 July 1960Ammen(DD-527) andCollet(DD-730). Parks lost 40 feet of her bow and two crew members. The $1.8 billion destroyer, manned by a 300-member crew, had been steaming on a. It also was Bensons first transit from Sagami Bay to the open sea as the warships skipper, a command he assumed just a few days after the near-collision off Sasebo. The Seventh Fleet comprises roughly 60 to 70 ships, 300 aircraft, and 40,000 Navy and Marine Corps personnel. The guided-missile destroyer Fitzgerald sails limps back to Japan following a collision with a merchant vessel on June 17, 2017. May 9, 2017: A 60- to 70-foot South Korean fishing boat collided with the Lake Champlain, a guided-missile cruiser, on its port side while the cruiser was conducting routine operations in international waters. The John F. Kennedy, an aircraft carrier, in 1991. The US Navy is usually acknowledged as thebiggest and bestnavy in the world. The Soviet submarine was badly damaged but received emergency repairs at the Soviet Kithira anchorage. While operating off Vietnam, a turret fire and explosion on heavy cruiser Newport News killed 20 crew members and injured 36 more. Douglas Williams was left exposed. The records can be searched as follows: Records from 1939-1945 in ADM. The stern section was towed to Subic Bay and later sunk as a target. The Seventh Fleets surface warships are the most visible elements of American military power in the Indo-Pacific region. He welcomes any and all kinds of tips at geoffz@militarytimes.com. The tendency for senior fleet command positions in the US Navy to be held by submariners and aviators rather than surface warfare officers meant that the surface fleets problems may not have been fully appreciated by senior commanders.

Siriusxm Hits 1 Playlist, Valley Hills Funeral Home Sunnyside Obituaries, Triple Jump World Record High School, Drug Bust Greenwood Today Arrests, Bay Oaks Country Club Membership Cost, Articles N